Megan Cline

The Social Security Swindle

government, ponzi, Reagan, scams, , Taxpayers, Thomas Jefferson, US Economy

Since birth, American citizens are given a number that binds them to the largest Ponzi scheme ever known: Social Security. It is precarious, deceitful, and a ticking timebomb on the economy of the United States. If that bomb explodes and social security payments stopped instantly, could the most vulnerable of society, the elderly and disabled, survive? The answer is likely no, and some simple math will show that social security is too unsustainable and irresponsible as a government institution.

Pyramid or Ponzi schemes are named after early 1900s Italian immigrant Carlo Ponzi. They are scams in which an operator gathers a small amount of investors and promises outrageous returns on investments to these initial investors. These initial investors are then incentivized to find more investors. The new investors’ money pays a partial amount of the money back to the initial group of investors, with the scammer pocketing as much money from these “investments” as possible. This continues until the scheme runs out of new investors. In Carlo Ponzi’s case, it took three months for the scheme to run into the ground. He left town, collecting over $15 million from his victims. His name has stuck to one of the most notorious scams in the modern world, and unfortunately, bears resemblance to the United States social security program.

The money that comes from American workers’ paychecks each month does not cover the benefits paid by the government to those who qualify for social security benefits. The money will run out. For simplicity’s sake, the following numbers and statistics are only applicable to social security benefits for retirement, and not for disability benefits, survivor benefits, etc.

A minimum of $69,200 (over the course of 10 years minimum) must be put into the social security trust fund in order to qualify for obtaining benefits, according to the Social Security Administration (SSA). $69,200 over the course of 10 years of monthly payments averages out to $576.66 a month. But the numbers don’t add up. The moneys the workers put into social security are insufficient to cover the costs of the social security benefits they will receive in retirement. That means the money is coming from somewhere else. The same document that outlines this minimum requirement also estimates an average payment of $1,907 a month to all retired workers in 2024. So workers are putting $576.66 a month into the social security trust fund, but after retirement are receiving monthly payments of $1,907. According to the CDC, the average life expectancy in 2022 was 77.5 years. With the age of retirement being 66-67 years old. That gives a solid 11 years or more in retirement. And 4-8 of those years are being funded by the workers’ of today’s paychecks.

There is always inflation to consider. The only way for a government to get more dollars out of a bank account than what was put there originally is to print more money or make up digital currency— which would exacerbate hyperinflation for the future generation. Numbers in the bank don’t increase automatically with inflation. The only way the SSA is able to keep up with paying out through increasing inflation is depending on current payers of social security who are paying according to the current inflation rate, an inflation rate that is likely going to increase in the future and therefore leave less and less money in the social security Trust Fund. 

Social security isn’t like a bank, where your money is loaned out and invested in businesses that will return a profit. Instead, the money is being transferred out of the pockets of the workforce into the bank accounts of the previous generation at an alarming rate. The money is eventually going to disappear, and it won’t be just the elderly and disabled who then feel the economic pains. “The principle of spending money to be paid by posterity…is but swindling futurity on a large scale,” said Thomas Jefferson.

Why would the SSA continue to exist if it doesn’t fulfill its own motto of “securing your today and tomorrow” and if the association itself doesn’t seem to make any money long-term from the system? “From these trust funds, we also pay the costs of managing our programs,” a statement from SSA reads. “We’re one of the most efficient agencies in the federal government, and we’re working to make it better every day. Of each Social Security tax dollar you pay, we spend less than 1 penny to manage the program.” When it comes to government employees, there is no incentive to get rid of Social Security and metaphorically rip up their own paychecks as the social security trust funds “pay the cost of managing our programs.” Nothing is stopping the monthly checks from rolling out on time, so why end a program that is paying the program employees’ bills?

So, what does America do with this systemized and well-ingrained Ponzi scheme? Instead of solving problems, it’s typical for government programs to grow in overreach — exacerbating the very problem the program intended to solve. If social security crashes or is purposefully cut cold turkey, it would end life-saving medical care, force retirees out of homes they would no longer be able to afford, and cause the unemployment of tens of thousands of government employees. Would these immediate disturbances and tragedies be worth the long-term benefits of a functioning economy? A Gallup poll from 2023 reveals that 61 percent of Americans say they would prefer a raise in social security taxes rather than cut benefits, and only 31 percent want to reduce the tax and cut benefits. In a representative form of government, these numbers mean it is unlikely any drastic measures will be taken concerning the dissolution of the social security program any time soon. Keeping social security around is about as brilliant as allowing Carlo Ponzi to continue stealing from newer and newer investors. But we may be stuck with this government agency forever, because as Ronald Reagan surmised “a government Bureau is the nearest thing to eternal life we’ll ever see on this earth!”

Leave a Comment