John Dewey’s ‘democratic’ educational doctrine advocates for collectivism, conformity, and exclusion. While Dewey wrote his main work in 1916, the political and social initiatives for the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) ideology carry philosophies identical to Dewey’s. The mainstream understanding of Dewey’s influence on the modern education system has been simplified into catchphrases like “Learning by Doing”, “Education as Growth”, and “Education as a Social Process.” Similarly, the professed aims of DEI are to “…deliver for the US people in an increasingly diverse, complex, and interconnected world.” These seemingly innocuous concepts harbor underlying ideologies that ultimately result in forced unity and exclude real diversity.
A closer look at John Dewey’s philosophy reveals that modern diversity, equity, and inclusion policies align closely with his vision of collectivism over individualism and conformity over diversity. The very title of his work in 1916, Democracy and Education, twists the underlying principles of the United States governmental form, which is a republic, not a democracy. Political thinkers like Locke, Machiavelli, Cicero, and Aristotle warned against pure democracy, favoring mixed or republican forms of government. However, Dewey defined democracy not as a legal structure but as a “mode of associated living, of conjoint communicated experience.” Dewey believes democracy is primarily a social system, which aligns with the DEI initiative to systematize collective ideology over individualism. In this framework, democracy becomes a means of social control rather than a safeguard for diverse viewpoints. His argument regarding the social aspect of education can be summed up in his own words, a punchy and telling phrase “a socialized mind is the power to understand [things] in terms of the use to which they are turned in joint or shared situations. And mind in this sense is the method of social control.”
With collectivism framing his entire work, Dewey’s enforcement mechanism is social pressure. Dewey advocates guiding behavior through shaming and social pressure, ingraining a desire for social acceptance deep into the attitude of the youth through this education. “Some courses of action are too discommoding and obnoxious to others to allow of this course being pursued. Direct disapproval is now resorted to. Shaming, ridicule, disfavor, rebuke, and punishment are used. Or contrary tendencies in the child are appealed to divert him from his troublesome line of behavior. His sensitiveness to approbation, his hope of winning favor by an agreeable act, are made use of to induce action in another direction.” This philosophy underpins many DEI strategies that rely on public shaming and group reinforcement to coerce ideological conformity. There is increasing pressure to issue apologies for perceived offenses, with cancel culture being one of the names of this mechanism. Public and private apology or acknowledgement sessions aim to correct behavior by compelling individuals to self-shame and train them to “notice and interrupt internal, interpersonal, institutional and cultural racism.”
While some educational analysts may argue that Dewey’s philosophy is not the driving force behind modern public education, the parallels between his doctrine and DEI policies implemented in the social world are formidable. The emphasis on collective thinking, enforced social norms, and ideological compliance reflects Dewey’s vision of a “socialized mind” as the foundation of democracy.
In a country founded on principles of diversity of thought, individualism, and rejection of oppressive authority, the ideologies of Dewey and DEI threaten the preservation of the unalienable right of liberty.
This article was originally published in The Rostra’s April 2025 magazine

Megan Cline graduated from John Adams College, class of 2025, and is the co-founder of The Rostra. With a deep love for the classical tradition, she enjoys exploring the ideas, cultures, literature, and people that have contributed to the intellectual heritage of the world.



