On December 7, 43 BCE, Marcus Tullius Cicero was murdered. The leading proponent of the Caesarian faction at that moment was Marc Antony. In the aftermath of the assassination of Julius Caesar, when the perpetrators and supporters of Caesar’s assassination had fled the city, Marc Antony roused the Roman population to honor Caesar at his public funeral. This was one of the all-time great acts of political pageantry ever staged. He also turned the people into allies of Caesar’s followers and enemies of Brutus and the other killers. But all were not of one voice; there were still supporters of the 600 year-old republic and its ideal of the people having a voice in government, the res publica.
Not content to allow Antony to hold the political field, Cicero delivered a series of fourteen harsh invectives against Antony in the Senate. These he delivered from the Rostra, the speakers’ platform, in front of the Senate House between late 44 and the spring of 43 BCE. These came to be called the Phillipics, vituperative attacks patterned after Demosthenes’ famous attacks on Philip II of Macedonia some centuries earlier. These helped stem the anti-republican tide but ultimately came to naught. When Octavian and Anthony reconciled during the first triumvirate, Anthony insisted that Cicero be killed. Octavian refused to sanction this at first, but eventually agreed to sacrifice the old consul for the good of political unity.
With the Triumvirate in place, Cicero was proscribed and assassins sent to dispatch him. At the time, Cicero was residing at his estate in Formia, a coastal city south of Rome, where he was preparing to depart for Macedonia to be united with the other Republicans. As instructed, an assassin cut off his hands and head and returned them to Antony in Rome where he had them nailed to the Rostra as a warning to others not to criticize the new regime.
Imperial forces were unable to consolidate their power under one ruler, and the civil war raged until 31 BCE when Octavian at last defeated Antony and Cleopatra at the Battle of Actium. Though it took Octavian, the victor soon to be anointed Augustus, fourteen years to finally consolidate his power, the Senate quickly poured titles, honors, wealth, and power upon him to show their acquiescence. Thus, the Senate became little more than a rubber stamp of his wishes and policies. The Roman Republic, with its more than 700 year history of government by the people, was finished.
Political change can be very slow, as in the case of Republican Rome’s fall into autocracy. But in our century, we have many examples of democracy disappearing in a very short period. Timothy W. Ryback, in his article How Hitler Dismantled a Democracy in 53 Days, notes that “On Monday morning, January 30, 1933, Adolf Hitler was appointed the 15th chancellor of the Weimar Republic. In one of the most astonishing political transformations in the history of democracy, Hitler set about destroying a constitutional republic through constitutional means. What follows is a step-by-step account of how Hitler systematically disabled and then dismantled his country’s democratic structures and processes in less than two months’ time—specifically, one month, three weeks, two days, eight hours, and 40 minutes.”
Many have created lists of behaviors (of varying length) based on Hitler’s rise to power which may be categorized as a Fascist Playbook. One author, retired Judge James C. Nelson lists, among other features, the following:
- Draw up an enemies list;
- Demonize any attempt to undermine the press;
- Lie, lie, lie (Hitler and his surrogates averred that a lie repeated enough would be presumed to be true, if not actually believed);
- Weaponize religious ideology;
- Bully, delegitimize and politicize the judiciary;
- Take control of the judicial branch and eliminate constitutional separation of powers and checks and balances;
- Destroy the Rule of Law;
- Politicize the civil service, military and domestic security;
- Involve government in surveilling the press, reporters, political opponents, those on the enemies list; and may I add undermining the freedom of liberal education in higher education;
- Weaponize and inflame racial and social prejudices;
- Fearmonger and demonize minorities;
- Disenfranchise voters;
- Subvert election results;
- Belittle and undermine the role of women.
During the runup to the elections in 2024, the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025 was made public. Many Democrats and news outlets were shocked by the 900+ page blueprint to change American institutions of government in the image of its authors. Immediately after his inauguration as the 47th president, Donald J. Trump wasted no time before launching into a series of destabilizing moves to ensure his near total control of many facets of the US government. Here are but a few:
- He has attacked members of the judiciary who stay some of his executive orders, even calling for the impeachment of some. His “border Tsar,” Tom Homan, has publicly said Trump would not abide by a court order that barred the deportation of alleged Venezuelan gang members.
- He has attempted to muzzle the press by stripping unfriendly news outlets of White House credentials, including the AP, HuffPost, and Reuters. Trump continues to challenge anyone who dares to point out his lies as manufacturing “fake news.” He relentlessly attacks Rachel Maddow, one of his most vocal critics, and calls for her to be fired from her job with MSNBC.
- His executive orders have resulted in the “mistaken” removal of names and biographical information of African-Americans and women contributors from US agency websites, the Arlington National Cemetery website, as well as other Federal agencies, such as NASA. This has included deleting mention of Gen. Colin Powell’s race as well as the “hidden figures,” African-American women and mathematicians who contributed so much to early NASA success.
- He has taken over control of the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in DC in order to ensure performances of his liking.
- He has, using his own words, “politicized” the Department of Justice to find cause to prosecute his personal enemies.
- Elon Musk and DOGE have crippled agencies, such as USAID and Voice of America, which Trump finds objectionable. Numerous courts have held these to be unconstitutional, but Trump claims DOGE has “nothing to do with the constitution.”
- Using financial coercion, the Trump administration is interfering with freedom of speech on college campuses. In truth, left speech and intimidation are out of control on American campuses and in need of reform, both inside and away from the classroom, but to overtly dictate speech and research is equally as reprehensible as the status quo.
- Trump has “unconstitutionally silenced” people living legally in the United States from “speaking, hearing, or engaging with viewpoints critical of the US government” through deportation and other means, says a new lawsuit filed by a Cornell university professor.
These represent only a few of the undemocratic behaviors that have marked the first few weeks of the second Trump presidency. Tragically, we do not have a man of Cicero’s moral courage to sound the voice of warning. Yes, as the constant stream of news shows indicate, there are countless voices criticizing the Administration, yet these are easily ignored as nothing more than noise, the buzzing of a gadfly. No one of serious political standing and reputation, such as our former presidents, is trying to rouse us with a barrage of Ciceronian-like Philippics. The Democratic party is, rightly so, in total disarray for standing by their heinous identity politics. While they are loyal to the country as the opposition party, they are simply a toothless, paper tiger. There are many on the right and on the left who disagree with Trump’s agenda and policies—but are simply too cowed or threatened to voice any level of outrage.
If we don’t stand up for the Democratic norms, practices, and institutions of the United States, we are nothing more than silenced and docile lambs. We are doomed to one day echo the sentiment of German pastor Martin Niemöller, who famously noted and regretted his involvement in the rise of the Nazi state by saying:
“First they came for the Communists, and I did not speak out Because I was not a Communist.
Then they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”
This article was originally published in The Rostra’s April 2025 magazine

Dr John Smurthwaite has a B.A. from BYU in Italian, a masters from Middlebury College, and PhD from Cornell University in Medieval Italian Literature and Language. John was formerly the Latin professor at John Adams College.



