Ari Johnson

My Experience with the National Park Service

federal land, George Washington, government, history, national parks

In the summer of 2013, I proudly stood outside Independence Hall in Philadelphia Pennsylvania as a National Park Ranger awarded me my Junior National Park Ranger badge. I was almost 16 at the time, so I felt a little too old for the title of “junior ranger,” but I had worked all day to fill out the paperwork, complete the scavenger hunt and successfully answer all of their historical questions, making me an official member of the National Park Service. 

This monumental experience was not my first interaction with the NPS and it wouldn’t be my last. My decidedly “indoor” family took an unexpected cross-country road trip across the United States one summer, camping the whole way. We saw countless historic and natural National Parks throughout our nearly three-month journey. What I thought would be a once in a lifetime road trip happened again and again over the next few years. By the time I was in my 20s, I had visited more than 40 National Parks across the nation and had gained an intimate understanding of how the NPS cared for federally owned land.

Desk of Alexander Hamilton at Hamilton Grange National Memorial, New York

The National Park Service is currently facing federal layoffs and staffing shortages following the efforts of newly elected President Donald Trump to shrink the size and government spending significantly. Early reports suggest that nearly 1,000 newly hired NPS employees will be terminated. Currently the NPS has approximately 20,000 permanent, temporary, and seasonal employees and more than 279,000 volunteers. Those whose employment has been terminated have appealed to the world of social media to raise awareness of the valuable work the NPS does throughout the nation. The public outcry has resulted in many rushing to support the NPS. “These workers take care of visitors in subtle but critical ways, from asking hikers how much water they have to gently making sure people keep a safe distance from wildlife,” one article states. Another article quotes Kristen Brengel, senior vice president of government affairs at the National Parks Conservation Association. She says, “Fewer staff means shorter visitor center hours, delayed openings and closed campgrounds. Trash will pile up, restrooms won’t be cleaned, and maintenance problems will grow. Guided tours will be cut back or canceled and in worst cases, public safety could be at risk.” 

People are upset at what appears to be a complete disregard for a supremely important government institution. I, like many Americans, believe in preserving the land of the United States. I also believe in preserving significant historical sites that safeguard the American story for generations to come. However, we must put distress aside for a moment and ask: is the federal government the best organization to accomplish these things?

Workbench in the John Adams Birthplace at the Adams National Historic Park, Massachusetts

Independence Hall is operated by the NPS. The only positive aspect of the federal government owning this site is that the tour is free.  After waiting in line for over an hour in the humid summer, a group of 40 people are shuffled through the “room where it happened” with hardly enough time to snap a few photos. Facts about the room are thrown at your face by a tired, overwhelmed NPS ranger who has been dealing with tourists all day long. You are quickly shuffled out of the room with hardly enough time to determine if the sun on George Washington’s beloved chair is a rising or a setting one. This kind of rushed, stressful, brief experience is expected from a free tour service of one of the most important places in American history and yet, I consistently find myself wanting more. I don’t care about a free tour nearly as much as I care to have an experience… one that will stay with me for the rest of my life. But experiences need time, care, attention, and money…things the government is usually terrible at providing. 

Canon at Fort Sumter National Historic Park South Carolina

My experience at Independence Hall is in stark contrast to my day spent at another beloved site, Mount Vernon. This place was the home of George and Martha Washington and lies peacefully on the banks of the Potomac River in Virginia. Entry is $30, far from the free admission cost of Independence Hall. You get to see the rooms where George and Martha Washington lived, dined, and studied. Admission includes a tour of the house that lasts more than an hour with ample time to experience each room as well as hours to explore the rest of the grounds that contain the gardens, outbuildings and working farms. Two of my most memorable activities at Mount Vernon were sitting in the rocking chairs on the back porch of the house for an hour looking over the Potomac River and reflecting on Washington’s life. Another was to visit the burial site of Washington, where a special wreath-laying ceremony happens each day. As long as you purchase a ticket, you can spend as many hours at Mount Vernon as you would like and go at whatever pace you feel like. The guides are knowledgeable, thoughtful and passionate about the history of the place. Following your tour of the estate, you can eat 18th century food at the Mount Vernon Inn Restaurant or purchase a thoughtful gift from the gift shop to commemorate your visit. 

Gardens at George Washington’s Mount Vernon

Everything about Mount Vernon is focused on providing you with an experience. The fate of the site depends on support from individuals since they do not have guaranteed funds from the government. The reason George Washington’s home can be seen by millions of people each year is not because of the NPS at all. The Mount Vernon Ladies Association raised an incredible amount of money through private donations, admission fees, and restaurant proceeds to eventually purchase the home from George Washington’s great-great nephew in 1860. This group of women still operates and maintains the estate today, and they are the reason that the home is preserved so well.

During another summer road trip I planned a visit to the home of beloved American poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. The home is a quaint yellow building in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and is owned and operated by the NPS. The ranger who gave us the tour was very knowledgeable, answered our questions and provided plenty of time to take in each room of the house. Our tour guide made sure we knew about Longfellow’s blindness during his life, which today would earn him the label of “disabled person.” We also were given a full and comprehensive lecture about the queer/lesbian history of the people who lived in the home following Longfellow’s death. The tour was 60 minutes long.

Longfellow House, National Historic Site, Massachusetts

Despite the progressive turn of our tour, I greatly enjoyed my time and wanted to purchase something at the gift shop to commemorate my visit. I was disappointed to find that the only things available were poorly taken photos of two of the rooms we had seen, badly made pencils with the National Park’s logo and the full library of the Queer history of America (which consisted of only a few books). I found it ironic that the only way the historic site had to make money—the gift shop—was poorly designed, planned, and executed. Once again I was reminded that though the NPS seeks to preserve historic sites and land, they have no incentive to either make an income by providing inspiring tours or to provide their visitors with a powerful experience.

Flannery O’Connor grew up in Savannah, Georgia, and today you can see where she lived and wrote for $20 Thursday through Sunday. Flannery’s home has a similar story to Mount Vernon, though she is not as well known as Washington. In the 1980s, the home was privately owned, very old, and in need of intensive repair. Bob Strozier, a Professor, heard that the house was on the market and he immediately gathered a small group of friends to raise money. They collected $132,500 in donations to purchase and repair the house. They gathered period furniture and furnishings to make it appear as historically accurate as possible. The whole process took years, and because of the money, time, and care of a few individuals, everyone can see the home of a beloved American author today. 

Flannery O’Connor Childhood Home in Savannah Georgia

I visited the home knowing hardly anything about Flannery O’Connor and never having read anything she had published. The guide who led us thoughtfully through each room of the house was perhaps the greatest Flannery O’Connor fan living on the earth. Because she had done a great deal of research, she was able to answer any question and tell us details about Flannery that she found buried deep in personal letters and diaries. It was clear that though the tour was only supposed to be 60 minutes, she would make herself available for as long as possible to continue answering questions. It was also clear that she wanted to be there and loved being able to share Flannery with us for as long as possible. The gift shop was full of Flannery’s books and short stories. They sold carefully handmade felt birds because Flannery loved them so much. I had a profound experience, and felt inspired by a woman I had never known or read about.  

Flannery’s Bedroom at the Flannery O’Connor Childhood Home in Savannah Georgia

The list could go on and on of both public and private sites I’ve visited but the pattern is roughly the same. The NPS offers a free experience at the risk of being shuffled through sites by apathetic employees who look like they would rather be anywhere else. You are given a quick informational placard to go through the important details, and a website that is difficult to navigate and doesn’t always have accurate information. Privately owned sites usually require an admission, but also a carefully cultivated experience, time, and endless things to purchase at a gift shop to remember your wonderful experience. In making our National Parks widely available and free, we have cheapened the experiences people can have there. The sites that preserve the most amazing moments in American history lose their value when no value is assigned to them. The NPS doesn’t have, and has never had the funds to compete with these carefully orchestrated private sites in the tourist industry. Anything the government touches ceases to work efficiently and the incentive for creativity and innovation decreases. Unfortunately for the anti-capitalists, yes, that incentive is largely money. And it works.

There may be no perfect solution to the problems of the National Park Service. But no matter which president is in office, the NPS will always struggle with being understaffed and underfunded. Government agencies always are. The solution is not to give more money to a department that has no clear incentive to use it in a creative and innovative way. It is also not to pay more people who may or may not be excited about the work they get to do. The only solution is to keep trying to be creative with what they do have, or to take the massive risk of trusting the American people. Can we trust private individuals to keep things safe at natural parks, to pick up garbage after themselves, to be respectful of very old things, and to value historic sites enough to raise money to save them? It is always a risk to step back and allow people to govern themselves but it’s the same risk that started this whole country in the first place. 

And what if the Mount Vernon Ladies Association hadn’t purchased Mount Vernon? What if Bob Strozier hadn’t started a foundation with his friends to buy the Flannery O’Connor house? What if we lost valuable historical sites to modern capitalistic factories, and natural sites to natural disasters? We could ask ourselves “what if” all day long. And sometimes no one will choose to preserve a so-called “beloved” site. Natural disasters may destroy vintage buildings, and old sites are sometimes torn down in favor of more modern and efficient buildings. But what if individuals in America get to determine what sites are most important to them?

Registry Room at Ellis Island Part of Statue of Liberty National Monument NJ, NY

Franklin D. Roosevelt is often credited with saying “There is nothing so American as our National Parks.” I, however, think that there is something more American than the lands that tell our story. There is nothing so American as the people who live here. It’s the American people who wrote our founding documents, who built grand estates and log cabins, who civilized the swamps and the deserts. It’s the people who developed the Oregon Trail, and traveled by wagon across the country to start new lives in the Wild West. It’s the American people who work every day to make this land what it is. The National Parks have shaped my view of America because the sites in this country tell the story of the American people. 

The mission of the National Parks Service is to value the National Park System “for the enjoyment, education, and inspiration of this and future generations.” Perhaps that enjoyment, education, and inspiration is best outside the hands of the federal government.

Lincoln Memorial, District of Columbia

Leave a Comment